Buying a used car instead of a new one can save you thousands of dollars up front. In addition, new cars depreciate as much as 20% in their first year. Younger drivers often buy used cars for their looks or performance. Older drivers do, too — but they often care more about practical issues, such as whether the car is safe, has comfortable seats and a smooth ride, and whether it’s easy to drive, park and get into and out of. And just about everyone, these days, cares about gas mileage.

Which used cars are likely to be of special interest to older drivers?* Here are some of the best on the market…

SUBCOMPACTS/COMPACTS

Toyota Corolla (2002–2007). The Corolla has many things going for it that will appeal to older drivers in need of a high-value small sedan. Though technically a “compact,” the Corolla is actually fairly large relative to the new class of ultracompacts, such as the Toyota Yaris, Honda Fit and Nissan Versa.

The Corolla has good head, leg and shoulder room for both front and rear-seat occupants. Also, it doesn’t have a steeply angled windshield/roof (as on some other models of compacts) that can make cars hard for people with limited mobility to get into and out of.

The Corolla has a fairly soft suspension relative to some of the more sport-oriented models in this category, such as the Honda Civic. The Corolla has performed very well in government crash testing, and later models will usually be equipped with safety features, such as antilock brakes, dual front air bags — and even side-impact air bags on newer versions.

Expect to pay: $5,000 to $18,000.

Chrysler PT Cruiser (2002–2007). This retro-themed, “all-purpose” car was hugely popular when first introduced, not only because of its nostalgic, custom hot rod styling but also because of its versatility. Its tall roofline and versatile interior allow it to efficiently carry cargo as well as people. It is much more maneuverable and less expensive to buy than a minivan, and it is also easier on gas, thanks to its economical four-cylinder engine (versus the larger, thirstier V-6s usually found in minivans).

PT Cruisers are also suitable for people with physical handicaps because they can be readily modified for both wheelchair access and hand controls. These vehicles have an easily accessed and roomy cargo area that makes them ideal for antiquing as well as longer road trips to visit family/vacation spots — or for bringing along pets. Later models offer the option of a convertible top, too. While the PT Cruiser is not especially refined, major systems are durable, and because they were produced in very large numbers, great deals can be had on lightly used models.

Expect to pay: $5,500 to $15,500.

MIDSIZE CARS

Buick LaCrosse (2005–2007). The LaCrosse is one of the “new” Buicks designed to appeal to younger buyers. It retains the traditional Buick characteristics of a plush and quiet ride, roomy interior and upscale but not ostentatious styling. This car can seat as many as six passengers (depending on whether the car has bench or bucket seats), comes standard with a smooth and powerful V-6 engine and is much more refined and “finished” overall than the Buick Century and Regal sedans it replaced. Even the older 2005 and 2006 models are still very current in terms of features and equipment, yet prices for slightly used models only a year or two old are extremely reasonable.

Expect to pay: $12,000 to $18,500.

Ford Five Hundred (2005–2007). Released as a new model in 2005, the Five Hundred is one of the most underrated midsize sedans on the market. It offers a standard V-6 engine and is available in all-wheel-drive, yet can be bought used for about what you would pay to drive a new front-wheel-drive economy compact.

Why is it such a great deal? When the Five Hundred was introduced, its plain styling and moderate acceleration resulted in slower-than-anticipated sales. Ford hurried a restyled version — with a larger, more powerful (and fuel thirsty) V-6 — into production last year and christened it the reborn Taurus. But the Five Hundred (and its Mercury twin, the Montego) are nonetheless just what the doctor ordered if the prescription is a great deal on a quiet, roomy and very comfortable five-passenger sedan.

Expect to pay: $12,000 to $20,000.

LARGE CARS

Toyota Avalon (2000–2007). The Avalon is Toyota’s largest passenger car. Compared with large American rear-drive cars, such as the Chrysler 300, it offers as much (or more) interior volume, but its front-wheel-drive layout means it has better traction in wet and snowy conditions.

The Avalon also has some of the highest customer satisfaction scores of any car on the market, as well as a reputation for high quality and reliability. Its large size also means that it’s a very safe car in terms of crashworthiness, yet it is easy to drive, with good visibility thanks to large windows and a rather high driver’s seat. Newer models may be equipped with a rearview backup camera, as well as side impact air bags and traction/stability control. The standard V-6 engine is one of the most powerful of its type available in this price/class.

Expect to pay: $7,000 to $25,000.

Mercury Grand Marquis (2002–2007). The Grand Marquis (and its slightly more spartan twin, the Ford Crown Victoria) are the last of the traditionally built full-size American sedans. These vehicles will be very familiar in layout to older drivers, who grew up with a roomy “big car” feel, rear-wheel-drive and V-8 engines, all three of which are standard Marquis features. The 4.6 liter V-8 engine provides easy power without having to mash the gas pedal, while the cavernous interior can seat six adults comfortably. There is a huge (21-cubic-foot) trunk, too. The rear-drive layout and heavy-duty frame allow this vehicle to comfortably pull a trailer. The car is simple and rugged and provides long service life and low-cost maintenance. The Marquis is exceptionally safe in a crash due in part to its size and mass. You would have to buy a much more expensive used car (such as Mercedes-Benz E-Class or BMW 5-Series) to find a car that scores as high on crash tests. The Marquis costs tens of thousands less when new and half to a third as much as those European cars when purchased used.

Expect to pay: $7,000 to $20,000.

PRICING AND MILEAGE

The wide range given for pricing in this article takes into account that used car prices can vary significantly, even when comparing cars of the same make, model and year, due to such factors as condition, mileage and equipment.

Check sources such as the NADA Guides (www.nadaguides.com) and Kelley Blue Book (www.kbb.com) used-car pricing guides to get a more accurate idea of the value of a specific used car, with specific mileage, features and so on.

Fuel economy will vary by manufacturer, model and year as well as different engine and transmission options. You can check the gas mileage for city and highway driving for a particular car by visiting the Environmental Protection Agency’s site at www.fueleconomy.gov. Click on “Find and Compare Cars.”

*I have not gone farther back than about five model years, due to mileage and wear-and-tear issues. The newer a used car is and the lower its mileage, the more likely it will be that at least a portion of its original new car warranty will still be in effect. This includes either bumper-to-bumper coverage for everything except normal wear and tear or longer-term powertrain coverage.

Related Articles